As some of you might not know... I did not pass my Candidacy Review on Friday. I understand why the decision was made and I was told why. But that does not match up to what was written on the review evaluation forms.
I was failed, because of my poor grammar skills. Ironically I had a friend go over my artist statement and I followed his suggestions(he passed) and apparently I did not get all the mistakes. They made me understand how important proper use of grammar is in the film industry and as an M.F.A. representing this school. Proper grammar at my age should be second nature. In the industry due to the large volume of resumes and scripts sent in one of the first things Executive producers, managers and employers look at is grammar. They might let one mistake slide, but no more then that. If more then one mistake is found, they will throw it away, giving it no second thought. So proper grammar is very important. They said to me "fix the grammar issue and we will pass you."
They then pointed out a few minor design issues with my DVD booklet: (all of this pointed out by Hofstein)
1. this should say Demo DVD Chapters not just DVD CHAPTERS.(its the only dvd in the case.)
2. Maybe move a few headings over here to the top instead of there on the side.
3. The page with all of the artists statement... make it more pleasing to the eye. invite us to read
it, so spread it out or change the font size.
4. 2 clips you have on the DVD have some color bleeding issues at the beginning and one some low contrast issue. "Nathan Blair was your dp? That is a problem he always had." Easy fixes you can throw a filter on in post.
This was it. All. I was a little confused, but I think it was mostly due the word "Failure" being on my mind. They asked me if I had any questions. I asked " did you read my thesis script?" They kind of looked at each other and then Hofstein said " what are all of the markings on the script?
I informed him that that is the director's analysis of the script. In each scene I have to locate the emotional turns, pivotal beats, facts, decisions and actions. This will allow me to communicate it to the actors while on set. "Well next time just give us a clean script." That is it. all. nothing more. ca-put.
I think Bulloch sensed my feelings and interjected "I do have to say this though, of all the students I've come across you have the strongest work ethic. Some of the students don't care, but you really give it your all. A strong work ethic is very important." He looked at the other two and they shook their heads up and down and agreed.
I shook their hands, thanked them for the information and walked out.
Well I got the evaluation form and didn't think to look over it while I was there. I just wanted to leave. Later that afternoon, 3pm, I pulled out the forms and read them. The majority of my marks were "needs improvement", "unsatisfactory" and a couple of "average" marks. This blew me away. Then I saw the last page:
My strength was the ability to accept criticism. My weaknesses were listed as follows:
1. "Unsatisfactory presentation of work."
2. "Inadequate thesis preparation."
3. "Unsatisfactory Directing work."
They never brought up directing material or thesis material. Since I was still in a state of shock I didn't ask. In my thesis preparation I included in my 35 page DVD booklet:
A. a script, my analysis of the script, two scenes shot for the purpose of testing shot design, a storyboard, and information on the conceptual style of the film.
(No one else in my department has shot their scenes in advance to test shot design. I HAVE! I know how important it is.)
They never mentioned my directing ability or information. In my DVD booklet, under each of the projects I had various bits of information which included:
Storyboards, shot lists, camera diagrams, lined scripts and a poster or two.
On the Dvd are:
8 clips from short films. All of which I have directed and only 1 shows no interaction between people.
So as you can see I was highly pissed. I wanted to go into a rage and take the Tendorizers sledge hammer to my junk car outside. But I digress. That would be counter productive. So I threw and beat a bunch of pillows, did exercises and contemplated my next move.
My next move has been to write a letter to the guy in charge of the reviews and the chair of the department for a clarification of information that was not communicated to me in the review. I'm not asking them to change their decision, because I know grammar is important. I am just asking for either those two lines be stricken from the evaluation form or at the least a clarification as to why they stated or clarification on information they have NOT communicated to me.
So I'm working on that. Ironically, I've had other students coming up to me telling me that they were shocked to hear I failed and that most of the people that provided books didn't half the information and design work that I had in my DVD booklet or DVD reel. I keep getting that. I didn't think people noticed my work, but apparently they do. Kumar told me later that on Hofstein's set, prof. Hostein walked up to him and said "You did very beautiful work on Chrisco's film 'The Gift'." So it blew Kumar's mind when he heard I failed. Hell Clark even went off today in the lab when I told him and he is Creative Writing major "does it say writing or novella classes on the front of this building. Your a film student. That's insane." The only good thing I can find coming out of all of this is the fact that other students are finding out how hard the review really is and that no matter what you do grammar is important. No matter if you think you have enough material in your booklet, go one step further. Hell my roommate got a glowing review and was told his book for the review was the best they had ever seen. He didn't even start work on the book till he moved in with me and saw what I was doing. He made mention to other students who stepped up their game. (he also paid $560 for his books. I paid $150. That is all I could afford.) But again other people gained something from my experience and that is a positive.
well there is my rant. I'm working it out and I'm also working on my grammar. I'll post pics of fonso later. But instead of a sour note here is a look at the set for the music video.. or portion of it anyway that Rick and James were on for their performances.

limited budget and all the wall still looked nice.